Are the funding rates on perpetual contracts Riba? Some scholars say they are just a market balancing mechanism, not interest.
Question context
CoinStudy's answer
Research opinion from the CoinStudy Sharia team. Not a fatwa.
The market-balancing argument is the most commonly cited defence of funding rates and CoinStudy has considered it carefully. The argument holds that because funding rates flow between traders rather than from a lender, and because the rate can be positive or negative, the instrument lacks the unilateral creditor-debtor structure that defines Riba. CoinStudy’s response is that this argument is technically accurate in describing mechanics but fails at the level of Islamic legal characterization.
Classical Islamic jurisprudence defines Riba al-Nasiah as any excess or addition linked to time on a deferred obligation. The key elements are: a financial obligation, a time dimension, and a payment calculated in proportion to the amount owed or held. Perpetual funding rates satisfy all three elements. A trader holding a leveraged long position holds a notional financial exposure. Every eight hours, a payment is calculated as a percentage of that notional amount. The payment is proportional to size and time. That the counterparty is another trader rather than a traditional lender does not change the legal characterization of the instrument: scholars including Sheikh Yusuf DeLorenzo, the AAOIFI Sharia Board, and the Islamic Fiqh Academy have consistently held that the form of the transaction controls the ruling, not the identity of the counterparty.
Furthermore, the market-balancing characterization describes the economic purpose of the mechanism, not its legal structure. Islamic commercial law does not exempt a Riba-carrying instrument because the Riba serves a useful market function. The prohibition is categorical. CoinStudy therefore maintains that perpetual futures funding rates constitute Riba under the HCS framework, contributing to the Haram classification of crypto futures trading as an activity.
Read detailed blog here:
Is Crypto Futures Trading Halal or Haram?